Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour


Submitted on
April 1, 2013
Image Size
896 KB


1,695 (1 today)
157 (who?)
Harvest Mare: Magical Melody by nickyv917 Harvest Mare: Magical Melody by nickyv917
Requested by jonbuddy

If Hasbro ever makes a legitimate MLP video game (not counting the iPhone game), it would be kinda similar to this.

Vectors by:
Fluttershy: :iconstabzor:
Applejack: :iconeipred:
Big Macintosh: :iconshadyhorseman:
Daisy Jo (Cow): :iconmylittlepinkiedash:
Chicken: :icondabupl:
Tank: :iconbrainchildeats:
Squirrelly (Flying Squirrel): :iconsitnich:
Badger: :iconboneswolbach:
Beaver: :iconmawscm:
Harry (Bear): :iconhourglasspony:
Ram: :icontimeimpact:
Flamingo: :icondaniel-h-n:
Winona: :iconmoongazeponies:
Pig: :iconblu-dawg:
Duck: :icontwilightpoint:
Bat: :iconemper24:
Toucan: :iconjoeyh3:
Kitty: :iconkatiepox:
Angel: :icontheseventhstorm:

Original cover: [link]
All rights belong to the creators of this game, :iconhasbroplz:, and :iconfyre-flye:
Add a Comment:
Okay, I'm going to potentially sound like kind of a jerk here, but critique is never usually 100% happy flowers and sunshine, so just bear in mind that my intent is to assist you as an artist, and not rip you a new one.

Vision wise, this is a neat idea, as Fluttershy and AJ are probably the best choices for this kind of game. Symbolically, they are the more "farm" ponies, the ones that take care of the animals, tend to the fields, etc. However this kind of thing has been done before, ponies crossed over with games, you know the deal.

That being said, there are some... Other problems I have with it. The quality of the edit is very... Low... Why is there a random N on Tank's neck? Some of the vectors are a bit pixelated around the edges, and the edit to the gamecube logo looks very choppy. It's a very noticeable edit. Not to mention some of the logos are a bit blurry. I think the best thing about spoofing game covers is that they end up looking like the actual game or they could pass as a real game cover, but there are so many jarring flaws in this one that I can't really get myself to believe that it would be a real cover.

Sorry, not trying to be mean, just trying to give the proper critique.
What do you think?
The Artist thought this was FAIR
8 out of 10 deviants thought this was fair.

The Artist has requested Critique on this Artwork

Please sign up or login to post a critique.

RenreiChan Jul 30, 2013  Hobbyist General Artist
I loved this game anyway. But now... Now my life is complete.
RenreiChan Aug 5, 2013  Hobbyist General Artist
NP ^^
it would sale like hot cakes and only take two months to create. those games are very simple. A pity hasbro got their hooves stuck up thier plots
I don't think this is in the right folder.
Fixed, and checked for other wrong folders. Should be fine.
Ok, just letting ya know :3
GT4tube Apr 21, 2013  Hobbyist Artist
Look nice! xD
Add a Comment: